"Uh-huh," Kate says, making it clear she doesn't entirely believe that. The pies are good, he's right about that, but Bitty likes Derek, she could see it that day they met him while shopping.

"Do you just like, purposely miss the moon eyes he makes at you?" she asks. "And do you ask everyone to gaze into your eyes so they can tell what colour they are while shopping? I'll answer for you. You do not, because you've never once done that to me."